Identity theft protection as an employee benefit: What employers need to know

What is identity theft protection?

Identity theft protection refers to services designed to monitor, detect, and respond to threats of identity theft that occur when criminals steal personal details such as Social Security numbers, bank credentials, or medical information in order to open fraudulent accounts, file tax returns, or obtain services. A typical identity theft protection solution combines continuous monitoring — of credit reports, the dark web, and other sources — with fraud alerts and a dedicated case manager to help victims recover in a timely and organized manner. Many providers also offer identity theft insurance that reimburses legal fees and certain costs associated with restoring an employee’s identity, helping limit the long-term identity theft consequences that can affect creditworthiness, employment eligibility, and financial stability.

Identity theft protection can cover multiple forms of fraud, including:

1. Financial identity theft. Criminals use stolen credit cards or bank account information to open new accounts or run up charges in the victim’s name. Credit monitoring and dark web scanning help detect this activity early.
2. Tax identity theft. Cybercrooks file tax returns using an employee’s Social Security number to collect refunds. Tax identity theft delays legitimate refunds and creates a maze of paperwork. Monitoring and proactive alerts mitigate the damage.
3. Medical identity theft. According to Allstate Identity Protection, the health‑care industry was the second‑most compromised sector in the first half of 2025, with 283 breaches affecting over 16 million individuals. A person’s medical records can fetch over $500 on the dark web, and victims may face out‑of‑pocket costs averaging $13,500. Medical identity theft protection monitors insurance claims and helps clear fraudulent charges.
4. Employment identity theft. Criminals may use an employee’s identity to apply for jobs or unemployment benefits, causing tax issues and reputational damage. Unemployment fraud is one of the top identity theft threats faced by employers.

Why identity theft is a growing risk for employees

The digital workplace expands the attack surface for hackers — that’s just a fact. Often employees sign up for payroll, benefits, social networks, and online shopping using the same emails and passwords. Phishing schemes and data breaches continue to rise: The Federal Trade Commission tracked 1.16 million identity theft reports between January and September 2025. Here’s a rundown on why employees are increasingly vulnerable:

1. Multiple identity theft threats converge. Employees face a mix of financial, tax, medical and employment‑related fraud. Health‑care breaches expose medical records, while tax fraud peaks at filing season. Attackers collect sensitive information and sell it on the dark web. In more severe cases, stolen data can be used for doxing and exposing employees’ personal information publicly. Furthermore, it increases the risk of harassment, reputational damage, and emotional distress. Stolen credentials also feed into new scams. According to Kasada’s account takeover attack trends report, in January 2025, criminals listed 2.5 million stolen accounts on underground marketplaces.
2. Emotional, financial, and time impact. A recent LegalShield study found that 77% of employees experience identity theft or cybersecurity issues. Resolving these incidents is costly — 78% of affected employees spend more than $500 in legal fees. Victims may lose access to bank accounts, accumulate fraudulent debt, and spend significant time restoring their identity, which takes a toll on morale and therefore productivity.
3. Productivity and corporate security. Identity theft restoration requires making calls, filling out forms, and monitoring accounts. Much of this happens during business hours. On top of that, compromised employees can become gateways for phishing schemes that expose the company’s systems. The latest IBM data breach report notes that breaches cost companies an average of $4.4 million in 2025, and 76% of affected organizations took more than 100 days to recover. Identity theft is therefore not just a personal problem — it’s a serious workforce and corporate security issue.

How identity theft protection works as an employee benefit

Employers can offer identity theft protection as part of their employee benefits package. The benefit is distinct from a retail product because it’s structured to protect the workforce as a group, often at lower cost and with features aligned to company needs.

Employer‑paid vs. voluntary benefit models

1. Employer‑paid coverage. In this model, the employer pays the premium for identity theft protection on behalf of employees. This choice demonstrates a strong commitment to security and can be rolled into existing insurance plans. The cost is typically deductible as a business expense, and the IRS treats the value of identity theft protection as non‑taxable and non‑reportable. The IRS clarified that services offered to prevent a data breach are also excluded from gross income.
2. Voluntary benefit. Some companies offer identity theft protection as a voluntary, employee‑paid benefit at group rates. Employees opt in and pay the premium via payroll deduction.

How employees access and use the benefit

Once enrolled, employees typically receive a welcome email with instructions to activate the service. They create an account and provide personal details necessary for monitoring their credit reports, Social Security numbers, bank accounts, and other sensitive data. During setup, modern platforms often rely on secure identity authentication methods to verify the employee and prevent unauthorized access. The service begins monitoring the employee’s identity across credit bureaus, public records, the dark web, and other channels. If suspicious activity is detected — such as new accounts opened or fraud alerts on credit files — the employee receives an alert via mobile app or email. A restoration specialist helps them file reports with law enforcement agencies, freeze credit, or dispute fraudulent charges.

Fit within broader employee benefits package

Identity theft protection complements existing benefits such as retirement planning, health insurance, and employee assistance programs. It addresses a rising source of stress that other benefits don’t cover. Including identity theft protection signals that the organization recognizes the contemporary realities of cybercrime and takes proactive steps to protect employees and the business. When marketed effectively, it can also help recruit and retain top talent — especially among remote workers and younger staff who prioritize security.

Key features to look for in employee identity theft protection

When comparing employee identity theft protection providers, look for a wide set of features that guard against the most common identity theft threats and simplify recovery. Below is a checklist to guide your evaluation:

• Credit monitoring and free credit reports. Continuous monitoring of credit bureaus for new accounts or credit inquiries. Employees should receive regular credit reports without additional cost.
• Dark web monitoring. Ongoing scans of dark web marketplaces for compromised credentials, bank account numbers, or Social Security numbers. Prompt alerts help employees change passwords or freeze accounts before criminals act.
• Identity restoration services. Dedicated case managers assist victims with paperwork, dispute fraudulent charges, and guide them through the identity restoration process. This personalized support eases the emotional toll of identity theft and saves time.
• $1 million in identity theft insurance. Coverage includes legal fees, lost wages, and certain costs associated with resolving identity theft. A recent Cloaked survey shows that employees value high coverage limits. A vast majority (80.1%) ranked identity theft insurance with up to $1 million in coverage as the most valuable benefit.
• Family coverage. Protection extends to spouses and children. Fraud often impacts entire households.
• Proactive monitoring and fraud alerts. Real‑time alerts notify employees if a breach occurs or suspicious activity is detected. Early warnings make it easier to contain damage.
• Device and online safety tools. Tools such as VPNs, password managers, scam alerts, and anti‑phishing education help employees avoid clicking malicious links and improve corporate security.
• Digital footprint management. A centralized dashboard shows where personal data appears online, helping employees control their information and request removal from high-risk sites.

Scams are in the air!

Save 71% on identity theft protection with fraud insurance

30-day money-back guarantee

View promotion details.

How identity theft protection for employees benefits employers

Providing identity theft protection isn’t just a gesture of generosity — it yields tangible returns. Here’s how:

1. Reduced productivity losses. Victims of identity theft can spend hours, days or even months resolving fraud issues. By providing robust restoration services, employers limit the time employees spend away from work.
2. Lower risk of corporate breach. Employees tend to reuse passwords or click on phishing links in emails. Identity protection services that include education, password managers, and dark web monitoring reduce the chance that stolen credentials give hackers access to corporate systems.
3. Increased employee loyalty and retention. Identity theft protection ranks high among desired benefits. Surveys indicate that more than 80% of employees value $1 million in identity theft insurance. Offering it demonstrates you care about financial wellness and helps retain top talent.
4. Enhanced employer brand and trust. Being proactive about security positions your company as a responsible employer. Considering that 58% of consumers lose trust in brands after a breach, showing you protect data and your employees can improve public perception.
5. Mitigated financial exposure. Data breaches cost organizations an average of $4.4 million per breach. Identity theft protection isn’t a silver bullet, but it decreases the likelihood of negligence claims and regulatory fines.

Is Identity theft protection worth it as an employee benefit?  

Identity theft protection may sound like an added cost, but the price is modest compared to potential losses. On average identity theft protection runs $6–$15 per employee per month. If purchased individually, plans range from $10 to $40 per month. Even a minimal breach can cost millions and lead to months of disruption or even put a company out of business entirely. When you factor in the emotional toll and productivity loss of employees grappling with identity fraud, the value far exceeds the cost.

Additionally, identity theft protection complements rather than replaces benefits such as retirement contributions, emergency savings plans, or student‑loan assistance. Where those benefits focus on long‑term financial goals, identity protection addresses immediate risks. By preventing losses and providing recovery support, it directly protects the financial wellbeing of employees and their families. It also resonates with younger workers who may not prioritize retirement yet but are tech savvy and concerned about digital threats.

Types of organizations that benefit most

• Remote and distributed teams. When employees work from various locations and devices, the risk of phishing schemes increases. Identity protection adds an extra layer of defense.
• Data‑heavy industries. Healthcare, finance, and retail companies process large amounts of personal data. The Identity Theft Resource Center reports that data breaches in healthcare alone cost an average of $7.42 million per breach. Offering identity protection helps mitigate reputational and regulatory fallout.
• Small and medium‑sized businesses (SMBs). SMBs may not have large budgets for cybersecurity, but they’re frequently targeted by hackers and have fewer resources to respond. A group identity protection plan provides enterprise‑grade monitoring at a manageable cost.

Scams are in the air!

Save 71% on identity theft protection with fraud insurance

30-day money-back guarantee

View promotion details.

How employers can add identity theft protection to their benefits package 

Identity theft protection is typically added as a standalone benefit or bundled with existing financial-wellness or cybersecurity offerings. Some providers combine identity protection with established cybersecurity infrastructure. For instance, NordProtect includes dark web monitoring, credit monitoring across major bureaus, financial account monitoring, and identity theft recovery services backed by insurance coverage. Features such as a credit lock and guided recovery allow employees to respond quickly to fraud without relying on internal IT or HR teams.

Here’s a quick rundown of what employers should evaluate the following criteria:

1. Assess your workforce’s needs. Review how many employees handle sensitive data, how often they travel or work remotely, and whether identity theft incidents have occurred in the past. Survey employees to gauge interest in the benefit.
2. Evaluate providers. Compare features such as dark web monitoring, credit and identity restoration, insurance limits, family coverage, and educational tools. Ensure the provider offers case management and a clear process for reporting fraudulent activity. Look for user‑friendly dashboards and responsive support.
3. Check legal and tax considerations. Ensure the plan complies with relevant regulations. As noted earlier, the IRS treats identity theft protection as non‑taxable, but contributions must be after tax.
4. Plan communication and enrollment. Clearly explain to employees what the benefit covers, how to sign up, what types of sensitive data will be monitored, and what to expect if a breach occurs. Provide training on best practices, such as creating strong passwords and recognizing phishing schemes.
5. Integrate with existing benefits. Coordinate identity protection with your HR portal or benefits administrator. Offer it during open enrollment and allow mid‑year changes for life events. Include identity protection in new hire onboarding.
6. Evaluate and adapt. Monitor usage rates, employee feedback, and incident resolution times. Work with the provider to refine the program, add features (such as free credit monitoring), or adjust coverage limits. Update policies as threats evolve.

Pro tip: Assign a dedicated internal person — often in HR or IT — to oversee the program. This person should ensure seamless communication between the provider and employees, track outcomes, and adjust the program based on feedback.